| The role of
Ontology According
to the language philosopher John Searle, creating social or political
ontology means describing the nature, properties, and role of
social entities. The "objects" represented by nations,
social classes, communities, associations, governments, banks,
universities, but also rights, obligations, powers, money, copyrights,
patents, have no real existence or physical identity, but fill
social life and are the object of any conversation on politics,
social behaviors, and justice.
Language created them,
their existence is based on international, historical, and social
agreements, and their meaning changes according to the various
social contexts, historical ages, and discourse levels. The role
of ontology is to describe such objects making explicit the meaning
assumptions in terms of minimal (meta)properties that may be universally
shared.On stricter, and more technical terms, ontology defines
concept meaning negotiations facilitating, especially on the Internet,
communication interchange, net interactivity, use of existing
lexical resources, harmonization of contents, and so on.
Legislation ontology
is the subset of social object ontology, which, in turn, needs
ontological assumptions on the real world, objects of social and
juridical reality. Both imply, and thus depend on, foundational
ontology. The foundational ontology upon which core ontology is
based (Core Legal Ontology CLO) is DOLCE + (Extension of
DOLCE, "Descriptive Ontology for Linguistic and Cognitive
Engineering", version 2.1 of D17 Deliverable Wonderweb, http://wonderweb.semanticweb.org.).
DOLCE was developed
by the Laboratory for Applied Ontology of the Institute of Cognitive
Sciences and Technology of the National Research Center in Rome,
collaborating with ITTIG for the development of juridical ontology.
The theoretical principles and assumptions on
which ontology is based allow representing the double dimension
(normative word/real word) in which the entities of the
juridical world are set: in Core Legal Ontology, legislation is
considered the description of the ideal way in which things
should occur in the world (situations). Of course, not all behaviors
interest the legislative world, not all norms refer to real situations.
In the juridical dimension, the "agents", which may
have physical identity or not, acquire roles: the function of
norms is to regulate actions in which they are involved, thus
associating legal effects to behaviors.
|